This review of Battlestations: Midway is among the most negative I've ever written. I don't doubt that WWII nuts may derive some pleasure from it, but by video game standards it hardly does anything right.
It always feels a little satisfying to slag off a game, though, if only to remind myself that my critical faculties aren't fading. I don't want to fall into the trap of scoring on a scale of 7-9.
Blog note: I've enabled anonymous commenting, but you still need to do the word recognition thing.