Hard to believe the year's almost over. I've got Assassin's Creed II still to play, and then that's probably it, even though there are several intriguing games I missed from 2009. The year-end period is always hectic and exciting, this year more than most. But there's always time to spotlight some blog posts that are worth reading.
-Ben Abraham's Permanent Death series is now available in collected form. Permanent Death - The Complete Saga is a 341-page PDF, complete with screenshots on every page, and a foreword by Clint Hocking. It's a great package, wonderfully presented, and I know it was a labor of love. I'm sure there would be all kinds of legal thorny issues involved with trying to profit off of this, but if you enjoy it there's no reason you can't chip in to fly Ben to GDC.
-Chris Dahlen's best of the decade list turns into a paean to Valve, which the company richly deserves. I agree with everything he says, and I would add that Valve seems to have internal quality-control standards that they ought to be sharing with other companies. Not only has the company never released a bad game, but they've also never released a game before it was ready, and when the waits for their games have seemed interminable, they have always also been justified by the end product. I have to think that's due to the corporate culture as much as anything.
-I enjoyed Brandon Sheffield's interview with Tetsu Takahashi about localizing Western games for the Japanese market on its own merits, but mostly I appreciated it alerting me to Ratchet's giant eyebrows in Japan.
-Jorge at Experience Points writes about the trend of setpieces in games, which replaces continuous, repetitive gameplay segments with shorter, self-contained, and scripted scenes. The setpiece approach is one I always like, even if it does result in shorter single-player campaigns. Also interesting to note is that watching just a minute-long clip of Uncharted 2 provokes an uncontrollable urge to play Uncharted 2.
-I liked a recent Hardcasual post titled "Samus Checks Map Again," but you should also read Chris Dahlen's Edge column about Hardcasual. Strangely, it lacks any mention of my publicly shaming them into relaunching the site last year.
-Tom Armitage pulls a lengthy Dave Eggers quote about the importance of creating art, and the pernicious influence of the critic. I can't argue the substantive argument, that sometimes you should put your nuts on the tracks and have the courage to create something. But there's always an undercurrent to comments like this that criticism serves no useful role, which I don't agree with. More to the point, I get the sense that somebody said something mean about something Dave Eggers did, and rather than deal with it he wants to invalidate the person's right to say it. Especially the part about "do not dismiss a book until you have written one," and so on -- that is the laziest, most kneejerk defense against criticism that I have ever read, and I would have thought that Dave Eggers was too smart to make it. Presumably you're allowed to praise a book even if you haven't ever written one, and specifically Dave Eggers' books.
Friday, December 04, 2009
Games of the decade: Far Cry 2
Part of a series of subjective looks at my favorite games of the decade.

I thought a lot about Far Cry 2 while I was playing through the Modern Warfare 2 campaign. Their approaches couldn't be any more different. MW2 leads you like a dog on a choke chain, viciously correcting you every time you stray off the pre-designated path. Far Cry 2 lets you wander and explore, and take time to plan your next move. It's slow-paced, almost meditative at times. Yet compared to the overstuffed plot and sloganeering of MW2, Far Cry 2 is the game that truly leaves you thinking that war is hell.
The dynamic approach means that Far Cry 2 is brimming with indelible moments that will happen to you and only to you, and which resulted in many players sharing their war stories as though they were real memories. I lost track of how many times I thought I'd planned the perfect assault, spending ten minutes or more skulking through the tall grass like a lion, marking all the enemy emplacements on my map, only to see it all go to hell once the first shot was fired.
Things in happen in Far Cry 2 that you can never account for. Weapons jam and misfire. The winds change, spreading fire back toward you instead of toward your foes. Enemies happen upon your rear flank by chance. Things can go disastrously wrong, or gloriously right. Though all these factors play into how the game develops, ultimately it's you, the player, who authors the experience. You don't have to do things in a prescribed way.
We all have our war stories. My favorite is a very simple one. I was on a mission at a train depot to destroy a tanker full of fuel. The depot itself was bustling with enemy activities, but I'd found my way to a ridge overlooking the place, right on the edge of the woods. From my perch there was a straight shot to the tanker. Perfect chance for a hit and run. I steadied my rocket launcher. Once I fired, I planned not even to stick around for the fireworks. I would disappear into the woods as quietly as I'd arrived.
It would have been a great idea if the weapon hadn't misfired. When I pulled the trigger, the rocket flopped onto the grass in front of me, smoking and hissing. I don't know what attracted more attention, the explosion or my hasty retreat down the side of the mountain. What had started as a surgical strike suddenly became a Black Hawk Down-style shootout. But I still had another rocket and some of the enemies, incredibly, were still hanging out next to the tanker. The explosion rocked them sky high, and when it was over, there was only silence.
More on Far Cry 2:

Far Cry 2
(2008, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, and PC)
(2008, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, and PC)
I thought a lot about Far Cry 2 while I was playing through the Modern Warfare 2 campaign. Their approaches couldn't be any more different. MW2 leads you like a dog on a choke chain, viciously correcting you every time you stray off the pre-designated path. Far Cry 2 lets you wander and explore, and take time to plan your next move. It's slow-paced, almost meditative at times. Yet compared to the overstuffed plot and sloganeering of MW2, Far Cry 2 is the game that truly leaves you thinking that war is hell.
The dynamic approach means that Far Cry 2 is brimming with indelible moments that will happen to you and only to you, and which resulted in many players sharing their war stories as though they were real memories. I lost track of how many times I thought I'd planned the perfect assault, spending ten minutes or more skulking through the tall grass like a lion, marking all the enemy emplacements on my map, only to see it all go to hell once the first shot was fired.
Things in happen in Far Cry 2 that you can never account for. Weapons jam and misfire. The winds change, spreading fire back toward you instead of toward your foes. Enemies happen upon your rear flank by chance. Things can go disastrously wrong, or gloriously right. Though all these factors play into how the game develops, ultimately it's you, the player, who authors the experience. You don't have to do things in a prescribed way.
We all have our war stories. My favorite is a very simple one. I was on a mission at a train depot to destroy a tanker full of fuel. The depot itself was bustling with enemy activities, but I'd found my way to a ridge overlooking the place, right on the edge of the woods. From my perch there was a straight shot to the tanker. Perfect chance for a hit and run. I steadied my rocket launcher. Once I fired, I planned not even to stick around for the fireworks. I would disappear into the woods as quietly as I'd arrived.
It would have been a great idea if the weapon hadn't misfired. When I pulled the trigger, the rocket flopped onto the grass in front of me, smoking and hissing. I don't know what attracted more attention, the explosion or my hasty retreat down the side of the mountain. What had started as a surgical strike suddenly became a Black Hawk Down-style shootout. But I still had another rocket and some of the enemies, incredibly, were still hanging out next to the tanker. The explosion rocked them sky high, and when it was over, there was only silence.
More on Far Cry 2:
Labels:
Far Cry 2,
Games of the Decade,
PC,
PlayStation 3,
Xbox 360
Thursday, December 03, 2009
Games of the decade: Bully
Part of a series of subjective looks at my favorite games of the decade.

Almost every Rockstar Games release attracts its share of controversy, but rarely have the company's critics played into its hands quite like they did with Bully. The horror, they cried, clutching their pearls. What sort of monsters would create a Columbine simulator, which is obviously what this game would be, since apparently it was set in a school of some sort? These critics didn't know what Bully was, and they certainly didn't care. They just knew that the evil people behind Grand Theft Auto were at it again.
Bully does share structural similarities with GTA, as well as that game's fascination with the underbelly of respectable society, but thematically it's more mature and thoughtful than any GTA game. It's about the soul-deadening effects of conformity, and the perils of blindly following authority. In Bully, it's not the snot-nosed kit who lights bags of his own crap on fire that's the problem, it's the entrenched administration and their lackeys in the student body. In a sense, Bully warns against following exactly the sort of people who would seek to ban a video game without even knowing what it is.
Credit also has to go to the design of Bullworth Academy, and a storyline that follows the course of a normal school year. I enjoyed the way holiday decorations went up and came down as the story progressed, and how friendships and alliances were formed and broken as the semesters went on. The school years used to seem so long while they were happening. Now I can't tell one month from the next. Bully captures that feeling of school as a battle, both literal and metaphorical. Where's the sequel?

Bully
(2006, PlayStation 2; 2008, Xbox 360 and Wii)
(2006, PlayStation 2; 2008, Xbox 360 and Wii)
Almost every Rockstar Games release attracts its share of controversy, but rarely have the company's critics played into its hands quite like they did with Bully. The horror, they cried, clutching their pearls. What sort of monsters would create a Columbine simulator, which is obviously what this game would be, since apparently it was set in a school of some sort? These critics didn't know what Bully was, and they certainly didn't care. They just knew that the evil people behind Grand Theft Auto were at it again.
Bully does share structural similarities with GTA, as well as that game's fascination with the underbelly of respectable society, but thematically it's more mature and thoughtful than any GTA game. It's about the soul-deadening effects of conformity, and the perils of blindly following authority. In Bully, it's not the snot-nosed kit who lights bags of his own crap on fire that's the problem, it's the entrenched administration and their lackeys in the student body. In a sense, Bully warns against following exactly the sort of people who would seek to ban a video game without even knowing what it is.
Credit also has to go to the design of Bullworth Academy, and a storyline that follows the course of a normal school year. I enjoyed the way holiday decorations went up and came down as the story progressed, and how friendships and alliances were formed and broken as the semesters went on. The school years used to seem so long while they were happening. Now I can't tell one month from the next. Bully captures that feeling of school as a battle, both literal and metaphorical. Where's the sequel?
Wednesday, December 02, 2009
Grateful dead
My review of Left 4 Dead 2 is up now at thephoenix.com. This is a terrific game, although it's not all on an even keel like the first one was. There are things that are absolutely brilliant, and some things that are kind of frustrating. What was great about the original was how simple it was, almost arcade-like: run from here to here, and shoot this, this, and this along the way. Left 4 Dead 2 adds a lot of wrinkles, many of which are spectacular, but which also take away from the elegance that made the first one so great.
For example, it's pretty cool that now you can choose different types of health items. A medpack lets you heal yourself or an ailing teammate, as before, but you can also choose to carry a defibrillator instead, which will revive a fallen teammate. That adds a layer of strategy that was missing before, but it also means that there will be plenty of times when you're carrying one thing and really need the other. The same goes for the temporary-boost items, adrenaline and pills. Adrenaline can be insanely useful in the right situation, such as when you need to retrieve an item, although the right situation rarely occurs.
And, as I say in the review, the more robust mission objectives are a double-edged sword (or a cricket bat, if you like). As soon as you're doing something besides running, you start wondering why you're doing these things, and most often the answer is nothing more than Valve saying, like an exasperated parent, "Because!" The Dead Center finale is the most egregious example, but even most of the Dark Carnival gives me this impression. On the other hand, Hard Rain is such a great idea that is so well executed, it's worth playing the game for that campaign alone.
Although the voice cast is just fine here, especially Cutty from The Wire,* I really miss Louis. We found ourselves saying things like "Pills here!" in Louis's voice, just so he would know he was loved. Honestly, I also miss the easier difficulty of the first game. Maybe our group is just terrible (okay, I know we are), but it feels to me like easy in the sequel is about equal to normal difficulty in the original, which was plenty hard for me. And this time they've stacked even more levels of difficulty, culminating in realism mode, which I will admit right now I did not attempt.
The Joystiq crew has caught some flak for their review of the game, which focused on nothing but the difficulty, but it's a perfectly valid point. I can't take more than about three resets per chapter before I'm done with the campaign, let alone five or more. The AI director this time is vicious about throwing the special infected at you, and never seems to adjust even if you're struggling. That's not the worst thing in the world, since the actual intelligence director can just switch things down to easy if you have no shame, which I don't. So while I'd take the first game over this one if forced to choose, it wasn't hard to make Left 4 Dead 2 more like the game I wanted it to be, and that game was pretty awesome.
*Be honest here: You would play a Left 4 Dead mod set in Baltimore, with the voice talents of Michael K. Williams, Wendell Pierce, Dominic West, and Felicia "Snoop" Pearson, wouldn't you?
Games of the decade: Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
Part of a series of subjective looks at my favorite games of the decade.
Trying to evaluate a game's historical significance in real time is not only difficult, it's impossible. Make a grand proclamation and you'll likely be proved wrong. Miss a new trend rushing at you like a tidal wave and you're myopic. Even superlatives of the "best console exclusive yet" are likely to be outdated within a year. No matter what, the most likely outcome with these kinds of statements is that you'll look foolish.
So we won't try too hard to build up the achievement of Uncharted 2: Among Thieves. And we shouldn't need to. This is a game whose considerable merits can speak for themselves, thank you very much. A robust single-player adventure featuring a diversity of environments and play types, it also benefits from a streamlined interface and a zen-like focus on the part of its designers. This is a game with nothing out of place. Everything in it is there for a reason, and I have to think that Naughty Dog's cutting room floor is knee high with discarded prototypes that they loved but couldn't fit into the final product without compromising.
Such great gameplay is matched by a great script. Nathan Drake is an appealing lead, although I have to say that his constant quipping didn't endear him to me quite as much as I think it was supposed to. The supporting cast is what really stands out, in particular the two female characters. They're both treated as Drake's equals, with goals and inner lives of their own. Refreshingly, at no time did they get catty in a fight for his affections. The way in which Chloe gives up Nathan as a romantic partner is a mature and honest moment that's unusual for a game. Honestly, if there's one way in which Uncharted 2 does end up influencing future games, let it be this.
It won't be, obv.
More on Uncharted 2: Among Thieves:
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
(2009, PlayStation 3)
(2009, PlayStation 3)
Trying to evaluate a game's historical significance in real time is not only difficult, it's impossible. Make a grand proclamation and you'll likely be proved wrong. Miss a new trend rushing at you like a tidal wave and you're myopic. Even superlatives of the "best console exclusive yet" are likely to be outdated within a year. No matter what, the most likely outcome with these kinds of statements is that you'll look foolish.
So we won't try too hard to build up the achievement of Uncharted 2: Among Thieves. And we shouldn't need to. This is a game whose considerable merits can speak for themselves, thank you very much. A robust single-player adventure featuring a diversity of environments and play types, it also benefits from a streamlined interface and a zen-like focus on the part of its designers. This is a game with nothing out of place. Everything in it is there for a reason, and I have to think that Naughty Dog's cutting room floor is knee high with discarded prototypes that they loved but couldn't fit into the final product without compromising.
Such great gameplay is matched by a great script. Nathan Drake is an appealing lead, although I have to say that his constant quipping didn't endear him to me quite as much as I think it was supposed to. The supporting cast is what really stands out, in particular the two female characters. They're both treated as Drake's equals, with goals and inner lives of their own. Refreshingly, at no time did they get catty in a fight for his affections. The way in which Chloe gives up Nathan as a romantic partner is a mature and honest moment that's unusual for a game. Honestly, if there's one way in which Uncharted 2 does end up influencing future games, let it be this.
It won't be, obv.
More on Uncharted 2: Among Thieves:
Labels:
Games of the Decade,
PlayStation 3,
Uncharted 2
Tuesday, December 01, 2009
Games of the decade: Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
Part of a series of subjective looks at my favorite games of the decade.

In my original review of Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney, I convicted the game of being awesome, which is an absolutely silly way to start a review but still accurately reflects my feelings. When I look at the list of my favorite games of the past decade, a part of me wishes it were less predictable. I wish there were more niche genres on there. I wish there were more commercial flops. In short, I wish there were something on there that I could champion. I think Phoenix Wright might be as close as it gets.
And why not? With its sharp writing, hilarious dialogue, and challenging but logical puzzles, the Phoenix Wright series is the true heir to the LucasArts throne. The discovery phase of gameplay, in which you walk around the crime scene looking for clues and talking to detectives, is just like something out of Monkey Island. And the trial scenes are thrilling, which I never would have expected when I first heard about the game. The driving music and anime-inspired backgrounds when the testimony gets heated makes these sequences as exciting as any shooter I've played.
In the end, what really sets Phoenix Wright apart is the strength of its protagonist. We've gotten used to playing games as macho superman whose only flaws are that they just care too much, damn it, and while Phoenix does value truth above all else, he's also a self-doubting wimp. He openly sweats during cross-examination, usually appearing more nervous than the witness he is trying to break down. He frequently requires pep talks from his assistants. In the end, though, his faith in justice helps him to prevail. I love that message.
After all the time I spent jabbering excitedly about Phoenix Wright when it came out in the fall of 2005, my editor asked if he could borrow it. I reluctantly agreed, and then he moved out of the state shortly thereafter. Damn him.
More on Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney:
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
(2005, Nintendo DS)
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - And Justice for All
(2007, Nintendo DS)
(2005, Nintendo DS)
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - And Justice for All
(2007, Nintendo DS)
In my original review of Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney, I convicted the game of being awesome, which is an absolutely silly way to start a review but still accurately reflects my feelings. When I look at the list of my favorite games of the past decade, a part of me wishes it were less predictable. I wish there were more niche genres on there. I wish there were more commercial flops. In short, I wish there were something on there that I could champion. I think Phoenix Wright might be as close as it gets.
And why not? With its sharp writing, hilarious dialogue, and challenging but logical puzzles, the Phoenix Wright series is the true heir to the LucasArts throne. The discovery phase of gameplay, in which you walk around the crime scene looking for clues and talking to detectives, is just like something out of Monkey Island. And the trial scenes are thrilling, which I never would have expected when I first heard about the game. The driving music and anime-inspired backgrounds when the testimony gets heated makes these sequences as exciting as any shooter I've played.
In the end, what really sets Phoenix Wright apart is the strength of its protagonist. We've gotten used to playing games as macho superman whose only flaws are that they just care too much, damn it, and while Phoenix does value truth above all else, he's also a self-doubting wimp. He openly sweats during cross-examination, usually appearing more nervous than the witness he is trying to break down. He frequently requires pep talks from his assistants. In the end, though, his faith in justice helps him to prevail. I love that message.
After all the time I spent jabbering excitedly about Phoenix Wright when it came out in the fall of 2005, my editor asked if he could borrow it. I reluctantly agreed, and then he moved out of the state shortly thereafter. Damn him.
More on Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney:
Labels:
Games of the Decade,
Nintendo DS,
Phoenix Wright
Monday, November 30, 2009
Games of the decade: Gears of War
Part of a series of subjective looks at my favorite games of the decade.

You always have to be wary of alleged system sellers -- the games that the fanboys are already proclaiming the greatest of all time well before a console has come out, and the reason only an idiot would not buy their favored, someday game system. Gears of War was one of those. Well before the release of the Xbox 360, partisans spoke of it with reverence. Even as it slipped to fall of 2006, a year after the console's debut, we were assured it would be well worth it. Naturally, I assumed the worst.
I was wrong.
Gears of War is a remarkably well produced game. In its way, it's as unimaginative as every other monochromatic, dystopian shooter, but the execution is at such a high level that it all seems fresh and new. Even the game's biggest draw, the cover system, wasn't exactly an innovation. It had been tried in a few games before, never fully successfully. Gears showed how it was done. And afterward, everybody else got on board.
That fundamental mechanic was reinforced by the larger game design: in Gears, you are always outnumbered and outgunned. Often you have to fall back and play defense, and even when you're pressing into enemy territory it is only yard by precious yard. The characters are designed to look like the biggest and baddest dudes around, but when the bullets fly they put their heads down just like anybody else.
Gears also plays on a more topical fear. From the premise, in which the Locust race emerges from subterranean caverns to ravage human civilization, to the ongoing and unpredictable appearances of emergence holes, the thematic subtext of the Locust is that they're all around you. They haven't traveled from across the ocean or from a distant star. They're here already. They've been waiting to strike. In my review, I made a half-hearted attempt to paint Gears as a post-9/11 game for this reason, and I still think that's probably accurate. Frankly, I wish I'd had the balls to go all the way with it and see what happened.
Gears 2, although it was bigger, better, and more badass, was missing some of the desperation and grit of its predecessor. However, Horde Mode was a blast, and something I also hope to see other games copy in the future (some, like Left 4 Dead 2, already are). As Tim Rogers said in his epic review, "Let’s go ahead and mint a brand new law to be obeyed from here on out by all those seeking citizenship in the kingdom of videogames: if your game isn’t fun enough to be enthralling in the context of an endless mode, nothing else about it means shit."
More on Gears of War:

Gears of War
(2006, Xbox 360)
(2006, Xbox 360)
You always have to be wary of alleged system sellers -- the games that the fanboys are already proclaiming the greatest of all time well before a console has come out, and the reason only an idiot would not buy their favored, someday game system. Gears of War was one of those. Well before the release of the Xbox 360, partisans spoke of it with reverence. Even as it slipped to fall of 2006, a year after the console's debut, we were assured it would be well worth it. Naturally, I assumed the worst.
I was wrong.
Gears of War is a remarkably well produced game. In its way, it's as unimaginative as every other monochromatic, dystopian shooter, but the execution is at such a high level that it all seems fresh and new. Even the game's biggest draw, the cover system, wasn't exactly an innovation. It had been tried in a few games before, never fully successfully. Gears showed how it was done. And afterward, everybody else got on board.
That fundamental mechanic was reinforced by the larger game design: in Gears, you are always outnumbered and outgunned. Often you have to fall back and play defense, and even when you're pressing into enemy territory it is only yard by precious yard. The characters are designed to look like the biggest and baddest dudes around, but when the bullets fly they put their heads down just like anybody else.
Gears also plays on a more topical fear. From the premise, in which the Locust race emerges from subterranean caverns to ravage human civilization, to the ongoing and unpredictable appearances of emergence holes, the thematic subtext of the Locust is that they're all around you. They haven't traveled from across the ocean or from a distant star. They're here already. They've been waiting to strike. In my review, I made a half-hearted attempt to paint Gears as a post-9/11 game for this reason, and I still think that's probably accurate. Frankly, I wish I'd had the balls to go all the way with it and see what happened.
Gears 2, although it was bigger, better, and more badass, was missing some of the desperation and grit of its predecessor. However, Horde Mode was a blast, and something I also hope to see other games copy in the future (some, like Left 4 Dead 2, already are). As Tim Rogers said in his epic review, "Let’s go ahead and mint a brand new law to be obeyed from here on out by all those seeking citizenship in the kingdom of videogames: if your game isn’t fun enough to be enthralling in the context of an endless mode, nothing else about it means shit."
More on Gears of War:
Thursday, November 26, 2009
Giving thanks
Often, I see people lamenting the lack of good games criticism. I do this myself sometimes. But really, the state of things is better than it's ever been, so long as you know where to look. On Thanksgiving last year, I took a time out to pay tribute to the many terrific games blogs that I read. This year, that list is longer, and once again it's worth giving a shout out to the great work so many people are doing. Below is a list of all the game-related blogs I'm subscribed to. Some are dormant, some maybe extinct, but all have justified their inclusion in my reader. If you see some unfamiliar ones in here, please check them out. You'll probably like what you find.
Thanks to all of the following blogs, podcasts, and miscellaneous sites:
- Above 49
- Acid for Blood
- Banana Pepper Martinis
- Big Red Potion
- brilli.am/writes
- chewing pixels
- Christ and Pop Culture
- Click Nothing
- collision detection
- Critical Distance
- Cruise Elroy
- Design Rampage
- Discount Thoughts
- Dubious Quality
- Eat | Think | Game
- Ed Borden: PWNING 9-5
- Experience Points
- Fierce Punch
- Finding the Fun
- Fullbright
- Game|Life
- Game Design Reviews
- GameInsano
- Gamers with Jobs
- GameSetWatch
- Giant Bomb
- Graffiti Gamer
- Groping the Elephant
- Hardcasual
- Hit Self-Destruct (RIP)
- Hot Fighting History
- Infovore
- Joystiq
- Jeremy Parish
- Kotaku
- Laser Orgy
- Magical Wasteland
- Man Bytes Blog
- MTV Multiplayer
- No More Gamers Anymore
- Noble Carrots
- Offworld
- Pixelated-Glee
- Press Pause to Reflect
- Rock, Paper, Shotgun
- Save the Robot
- Sexy Videogameland
- Shawn Elliott
- SLRC
- The Autumnal City
- The Brainy Gamer
- The Cut Scene
- The Escapist: Zero Punctuation
- The Quixotic Engineer
- Valuable Games
- Versus CluClu Land
- Vorpal Bunny Ranch
- You Have Lost!
Wednesday, November 25, 2009
Games of the decade: An introduction
You might have heard that the end of the decade is approaching. If you read, well, anything, you might also know that everybody with an opinion has to rank their favorite everything of the decade. It's the law. Who am I to flout convention? Over the next few weeks, I'll be sharing with you my favorite games of the aughts.
This isn't intended to be a definitive or an objective list. It's not the "best" of the decade, nor a list of the most important or influential games. Although they'll be published in somewhat ascending order, they're not even ranked. I'm framing it this way for a couple reasons. One is simply that there are huge gaps in my gaming knowledge, especially from the first few years of the decade. At that time, I was dirt poor and nobody was sending me anything for free, so I missed out on some likely favorites by circumstance. Plus, the last thing I want to do is get into a futile debate about which games are ranked too low or too high, as though there were a mathematical formula involved.
Instead, I want to do two things. First, whatever your thoughts are on these types of lists, I think it's nice, every once in awhile, to stop and appreciate what we already have. Ten years is a lifetime in the video game industry. In the year 2000, publishers were still releasing games for the N64. The PS2 was about to come out. Xbox Live was a gleam in J Allard's eye. PC gamers were buzzing about something called Deus Ex. That was all this decade! It's astonishing. I'd like to celebrate that.
Second, these writeups will be wholly subjective. I haven't written them all yet, so I can't say to what extent this will be the case, but they're not intended to be penetrating critical essays, or even garden-variety reviews. Playing games can be an intensely personal experience, and wherever possible I'd like to talk about the circumstances in which I played a game that turned out to be a favorite, or in which certain games have guided and shaped my approach to writing about all games.
That's the game plan. I'll be posting one game every day beginning on Monday, and continuing throughout the month of December. I hope you enjoy it! If not, it was nice having a thousand subscribers for a while there.
Tuesday, November 24, 2009
A well past due Modern Warfare 2 review
My review of Modern Warfare 2 is up now at thephoenix.com. After playing long enough not to totally embarrass myself in multiplayer (harder to do than you'd realize), I settled in on liking it, but not loving it. The multiplayer is fully featured and robust, if the single-player is much less effective than that of Call of Duty 4. So it's good, not great.
I find myself asking the same question I always ask when a game is this commercially successful: Why this game? Why Modern Warfare 2 and not, say, Killzone 2? I'd put those games about on par in terms of quality. They both have splashy, unsatisfying campaigns, and deep multiplayer modes with tons of character progression and unlocks (excessively so, in the latter case). Yet Killzone is already forgotten, while MW2 is the biggest entertainment launch of all time. It's strange.
That said, it's certainly not a negative review, and I'm glad to have had a chance to play the game. I hope that Infinity Ward shows a little more restraint the next time out as far as the campaign goes, but they have a solid multiplayer foundation that's obviously working for a lot of people. What can you do but tip your cap to them?
Labels:
Modern Warfare 2,
PC,
PlayStation 3,
Reviews,
Xbox 360
Monday, November 23, 2009
Leveling the playing field
Designing a multiplayer game has got to be tricky. With a single-player game, a player who finds the game too easy or too hard can usually make an in-game adjustment to suit his tastes. In multiplayer, that's not possible, especially in a game like Modern Warfare 2, in which new players are constantly rotating in. The risk is that players who are much better than average will tend to dominate, while players who are much worse than average will have a hard time competing. And that's not fun for anybody.
Developers generally choose from at least one of three approaches to level the playing field:
- Match players by skill
- Give help to bad players
- Give incentives to good players
Giving help to bad players is a good idea, but it has to be done delicately. Nobody thinks it's fair when the best player loses thanks to heavyhanded intervention by the game gods. How many times have you been cruising to a victory in Mario Kart, only to be undone by a succession of lightning bolts and purple shells? Often in games like that, it seems like being skillful is a detriment. What you want to be is second best, so you can zip past the leader right after Zeus strikes him down.
Incentivizing good play tends to work the best. In Modern Warfare 2, you earn XP for killing an opponent, but you earn more XP for killing him with a headshot. That's a nice touch. You're rewarded for being good, without being punished for not being quite as good. On the other hand, the killstreak rewards can seem like a case of the rich getting richer. It's not easy to get a killstreak long enough to call in the heavy artillery, and when you're still hanging out at the bottom of the learning curve, little is more terrifying than hearing the whine of your opponent's jump jet hovering over the battlefield. 25 kills in a row gives you the ability to deploy a tactical nuke -- if you can kill 25 people in a row without dying, you basically are a tactical nuke.
But the killstreaks are balanced nicely. They don't get out of hand. For one thing, I initially thought that you could only use one reward per killstreak -- i.e., call in your UAV after three kills, and your counter resets to zero -- but it turns out that you can use each killstreak ability as it comes. And the UAV is even persistent, after a brief cooldown. A big killstreak may be hard to come by, but even a mediocre player can occasionally luck into smaller ones, and it's nice to know they will be immediately rewarded.
Infinity Ward's other good idea is the deathstreak, lower-level help given to players who are getting killed over and over with nothing to show for it. Die a few times in a row and you're given the option to steal another player's class. It's a good way to switch it up when things aren't working for you. Die a little more and you might get the "last stand" perk, which lets you keep firing for a moment after dying. It's a smart way to keep bad players in the game without giving them an inordinate amount of help. If Modern Warfare followed the Mario Kart model, then the tactical nuke would come from a deathstreak.
Overall, the multiplayer is very well balanced. The best reap the biggest rewards, but the worst have a strong safety net. And for the rest of us in the middle, we are at least competitive, and who knows? Maybe the next care package will have that nuke in it.
Friday, November 20, 2009
Friday afternoon tidbits-
Nobody's asked how NaNoWriMo is going, but I'll tell you anyway: I expect to cross the 50,000 word mark tonight or tomorrow, although the story itself will go on for a bit longer. It's been a rewarding, if taxing, experience, and I'd recommend anybody who's ever thought about writing a book give it a go next year. Or, hell, just try it in December! Writing is sweet.
-Kyle Orland has the definitive look at the Left 4 Dead 2 boycott. Not having paid attention to any of it while it was happening, I didn't realize there was a story with so many twists and turns. This just proves, once again, that Valve is one of the smartest companies around. But the boycotters made their point too, and overall the whole thing seems much more successful than the MW2 boycott.
-Speaking of MW2, I don't see a need to weigh in on the "No Russian" scene because so many others have already said basically what I would have, only better -- Kieron Gillen and Tom Chick chief among them. Nick Dinicola has a more sanguine take, arguing that Modern Warfare 2 accurately reflects the senseless state of warfare in the 21st century. He may not be totally wrong about that, but it's important to remember the extent to which we've sanitized World War II in our collective memory. Maybe there was a good reason for fighting it, but you can't tell that to the 50 million people who died, the majority of them civilians.
-Also at PopMatters, L.B. Jeffries stands up for the merits of linear narrative. He's right to frame it the way he does -- there's always a lot of excitement about emergent narratives and player-as-author design philosophies, but there's room for more than one approach. Well-scripted, linear games may not be sexy, but they'll never go out of style.
-Steve Gaynor puts together his picks for the definitive games of the decade, which he says "defined the state of the art in game design in the 00's." Good list with lots to think about. Like one of the commenters, I too think that Guitar Hero and Rock Band should be on that list in some form. They are simply too big a cultural and commercial phenomenon to ignore, and although music and rhythm games had existed in some form before, the original Guitar Hero is clearly the demarcation point between the genre as a niche and as a powerhouse.
-Sarah Palin may think she's going rogue, but it turns out to be a pretty weak build.
-Kyle Orland has the definitive look at the Left 4 Dead 2 boycott. Not having paid attention to any of it while it was happening, I didn't realize there was a story with so many twists and turns. This just proves, once again, that Valve is one of the smartest companies around. But the boycotters made their point too, and overall the whole thing seems much more successful than the MW2 boycott.
-Speaking of MW2, I don't see a need to weigh in on the "No Russian" scene because so many others have already said basically what I would have, only better -- Kieron Gillen and Tom Chick chief among them. Nick Dinicola has a more sanguine take, arguing that Modern Warfare 2 accurately reflects the senseless state of warfare in the 21st century. He may not be totally wrong about that, but it's important to remember the extent to which we've sanitized World War II in our collective memory. Maybe there was a good reason for fighting it, but you can't tell that to the 50 million people who died, the majority of them civilians.
-Also at PopMatters, L.B. Jeffries stands up for the merits of linear narrative. He's right to frame it the way he does -- there's always a lot of excitement about emergent narratives and player-as-author design philosophies, but there's room for more than one approach. Well-scripted, linear games may not be sexy, but they'll never go out of style.
-Steve Gaynor puts together his picks for the definitive games of the decade, which he says "defined the state of the art in game design in the 00's." Good list with lots to think about. Like one of the commenters, I too think that Guitar Hero and Rock Band should be on that list in some form. They are simply too big a cultural and commercial phenomenon to ignore, and although music and rhythm games had existed in some form before, the original Guitar Hero is clearly the demarcation point between the genre as a niche and as a powerhouse.
-Sarah Palin may think she's going rogue, but it turns out to be a pretty weak build.
Thursday, November 19, 2009
Draggin' age
At long last, now that I've lost any interest in talking about it further, my review of Dragon Age: Origins is up at thephoenix.com.
I am pretty happy with the way this one came out. It is no fun to feel like the person on the outside, when everybody else seems to be loving a game that you just don't get. Fortunately, thanks in large part to your comments, I felt like I did come to a pretty decent understanding of the whole thing before I had to write about it. Even if that wasn't enough to change my opinion, it did help me to state it more clearly (and Krystian Majewski's Mass Effect essay was a big help, too). Dragon Age is such a big game that it's impossible to cover everything in 600 words and still make a point, but I feel like this one came close.
We are still in the thick of things, reviews-wise. All the whinging about Holiday 2009 delays is laughable in hindsight. This fall has turned out to be stacked. I feel pretty confident that I've already played my game of the year, but with Left 4 Dead 2, Assassin's Creed 2, and New Super Mario Brothers Wii all theoretically on the docket, that could change in a heartbeat. Now if only anybody would send me any of these games...
Labels:
Dragon Age Origins,
PC,
PlayStation 3,
Reviews,
Xbox 360
Friday, November 13, 2009
Friday afternoon tidbits
Some thanks are in order. First, to everybody who suggested gaming blogs last week, thanks for some excellent suggestions, and some new reading material. And second, I'm really appreciative of the thread that developed on the Dragon Age post earlier in the week. I still can't say I like the game, but I understand it much better now, and can say that I have more respect for what it sets out to accomplish. (Undermining that statement in 3... 2... 1...)
-The best blog post I've read this year is Krystian Majewski's three-part dissection of the interface problems in Mass Effect. In exacting detail, and with illustrative screenshots, Krystian pores over the numerous bad decisions, both large and small, that make playing Mass Effect such a trial. Upon reading this series, I realized two things:
-The crew at Gamers with Jobs are such sharp and perceptive writers that when they go wrong, you can almost hear the needle scratching off the record. Sean "Elysium" Sands writes in "A Dirge for the Sinking Ship" that gamers are inadvertently hastening the demise of high-quality, original games by making stupid demands and engaging in silly boycotts. Elysium himself admits to an "unfocussed rage," which is something of an understatement. I think I understand his sentiment, but his logic is baffling.
The linchpin of his argument is that people who complain about day-one DLC in Dragon Age are shortsighted and greedy. Certainly nobody would argue that the game, as it shipped, is lacking content. That's part of why people are upset, I think. You just spent $60 on a new game, thinking you'll settle in for 50 hours or so, and within about 5 hours of play an NPC is hitting you up for actual money. I am not outraged by this, but I think gamers are well within their rights not to buy it, and to let the company know why. That's how the market is supposed to work.
Elysium's larger, self-defeating argument is that if we want to avoid a future with crippled retail products and day-one DLC, then we are obligated to... buy day-one DLC. Well, I don't buy that. Publishers aren't stupid. The way to ensure more games like Dragon Age is to buy Dragon Age. The way to ensure more DLC is to buy DLC. And for the dubious efficacy of things like boycotts -- especially half-hearted ones -- it does work when gamers make their voices heard. The infamous horse armor from Oblivion is the go-to example of stupid, overpriced DLC, and what happened there? There was an outcry, Bethesda responded, and future add-ons were more fairly priced and offered a greater value.
Nearly all of the examples Elysium points to as games we'll be missing out on in the future -- remember, the future after we haven't bought Dragon Age DLC -- are strange ones. Mirror's Edge was a fine idea but a bad game. Ghostbusters was all right, nothing special, and hardly an example of what I'd call a risky game. Brutal Legend was inspired, but a mess. The Riddick remake was great, but it was a remake of a commercially successful title, which tells me that they've already sheared that sheep as much as they're going to.
And then -- Dead Space? Uncharted 2? Fallout 3? Borderlands? We're afraid there won't be more games like these? These are all huge hits. They're all packed with great content on the disc, full experiences in themselves, with some optional DLC if you're into that sort of thing. I guarantee you that we will be seeing more games like these. And if the concern is that we'll only be seeing games like these, which is to say sequels to these games, well, some of them are sequels already. Besides which, these are all games that have come out in the past year, not long-forgotten relics of a more creative era.
There is something to the argument that the à la carte model prohibits systemic support for smaller and riskier projects -- there are so many niche cable television channels today because subscribers have so little choice in which ones we get, so we end up pooling our money for all of them. But a simple look at the state of independent games, especially through digital distribution platforms like Steam, would seem to put the lie to that, too. Anyway, I'd really recommend you read the piece and the top-notch comments thread that follows. Many great points have been made on both sides.
-This is making the rounds. And it is very funny.
Happy weekend!
-The best blog post I've read this year is Krystian Majewski's three-part dissection of the interface problems in Mass Effect. In exacting detail, and with illustrative screenshots, Krystian pores over the numerous bad decisions, both large and small, that make playing Mass Effect such a trial. Upon reading this series, I realized two things:
- Dragon Age's interface is a marked improvement over Mass Effect's.
- Dragon Age's interface is still terrible.
-The crew at Gamers with Jobs are such sharp and perceptive writers that when they go wrong, you can almost hear the needle scratching off the record. Sean "Elysium" Sands writes in "A Dirge for the Sinking Ship" that gamers are inadvertently hastening the demise of high-quality, original games by making stupid demands and engaging in silly boycotts. Elysium himself admits to an "unfocussed rage," which is something of an understatement. I think I understand his sentiment, but his logic is baffling.
The linchpin of his argument is that people who complain about day-one DLC in Dragon Age are shortsighted and greedy. Certainly nobody would argue that the game, as it shipped, is lacking content. That's part of why people are upset, I think. You just spent $60 on a new game, thinking you'll settle in for 50 hours or so, and within about 5 hours of play an NPC is hitting you up for actual money. I am not outraged by this, but I think gamers are well within their rights not to buy it, and to let the company know why. That's how the market is supposed to work.
Elysium's larger, self-defeating argument is that if we want to avoid a future with crippled retail products and day-one DLC, then we are obligated to... buy day-one DLC. Well, I don't buy that. Publishers aren't stupid. The way to ensure more games like Dragon Age is to buy Dragon Age. The way to ensure more DLC is to buy DLC. And for the dubious efficacy of things like boycotts -- especially half-hearted ones -- it does work when gamers make their voices heard. The infamous horse armor from Oblivion is the go-to example of stupid, overpriced DLC, and what happened there? There was an outcry, Bethesda responded, and future add-ons were more fairly priced and offered a greater value.
Nearly all of the examples Elysium points to as games we'll be missing out on in the future -- remember, the future after we haven't bought Dragon Age DLC -- are strange ones. Mirror's Edge was a fine idea but a bad game. Ghostbusters was all right, nothing special, and hardly an example of what I'd call a risky game. Brutal Legend was inspired, but a mess. The Riddick remake was great, but it was a remake of a commercially successful title, which tells me that they've already sheared that sheep as much as they're going to.
And then -- Dead Space? Uncharted 2? Fallout 3? Borderlands? We're afraid there won't be more games like these? These are all huge hits. They're all packed with great content on the disc, full experiences in themselves, with some optional DLC if you're into that sort of thing. I guarantee you that we will be seeing more games like these. And if the concern is that we'll only be seeing games like these, which is to say sequels to these games, well, some of them are sequels already. Besides which, these are all games that have come out in the past year, not long-forgotten relics of a more creative era.
There is something to the argument that the à la carte model prohibits systemic support for smaller and riskier projects -- there are so many niche cable television channels today because subscribers have so little choice in which ones we get, so we end up pooling our money for all of them. But a simple look at the state of independent games, especially through digital distribution platforms like Steam, would seem to put the lie to that, too. Anyway, I'd really recommend you read the piece and the top-notch comments thread that follows. Many great points have been made on both sides.
-This is making the rounds. And it is very funny.
Happy weekend!
Labels:
DLC,
Dragon Age Origins,
Friday Afternoon Tidbits,
Mass Effect
Tuesday, November 10, 2009
Dragon Rage
Every so often, maybe once a year, there's a game that stymies me. Often, this game is made by BioWare. The current culprit is Dragon Age: Origins. Before we get to the opinion part, first I want to lay out some facts.
- This game has apparently been in development for at least five years.
- I never heard of it before about two weeks ago.
- I cannot look at a message board or Twitter stream without drowning in praise for the game, along with in-depth discussions of tactics.
Let's start with an admission: I am not a smart man. Oh, I know some fancy words, and I quote only the most highbrow cartoon shows,* but when it comes to mastering new systems and making long-range plans, I am less than useless. It might be stubbornness more than anything. When my party gets wiped out in Dragon Age, my usual response is to rush right back into the scrum, pressing the "attack" button more forcefully this time. This is obviously not the way you are intended to play.
But how the hell are you supposed to play? The game doesn't teach you. It lets you unlock a lot of powers and abilities, and it explains what those activities do in the most obscure and inscrutable of ways. This doesn't seem to be a problem among interfriends, whose earnest discussions about aggro and pulling are both easy and free. I, well, I don't know what these words mean in a practical sense. People and video games who employ them so casually do not make it easy to find out.
I want to enjoy the big-picture stuff that makes Dragon Age so appealing. Sword-and-sorcery is not my favored domain, which leads to a dilemma: One one hand, it's lazy and unfair to criticize a game for its genre. You wouldn't criticize Madden for being a football game, or Call of Duty for being a military shooter. On the other hand, if you didn't like football games or military shooters, what could convince you that those were better-than-average examples of their types? It's okay not to like a genre or a style of game, but not to damn them for existing.
Even so, I was cruising along with Dragon Age for a little while, not loving it or even really enjoying myself, but at least progressing. Then, when my party got wiped out at one point, I selected the default continue option. I didn't even read the menu; I just hit A when it came up. I think it said something about loading my last save, or last checkpoint, but whatever it said, I expected to start back at the area I'd entered most recently. I certainly did not expect to be transported back in time about an hour, before I'd accepted several quests and finished one or two others. Suddenly I was back in the middle of a pitched battle I'd easily won the first time through, and for some reason my party no longer seemed up to the task. We were getting slaughtered. And some significant progress was lost forever.
This is the kind of thing that's a dealbreaker for me. I can see how the depth of a complex RPG like Dragon Age can appeal to other people, even if it doesn't appeal to me. What I don't understand is how a game that can make that egregious and basic an error is supposed to make me want to join the club. The same thing happened in Mass Effect: I reached a part I couldn't seem to get by, but because of the checkpoint and auto-save system, as well as the quest structure, I couldn't leave the area, either. I must have thrown myself at it a dozen times. Finally my choice was either to start a new game or give up. I gave up, and spent several weeks afterward smoldering, especially as I read all the glowing chatter about the game online.
Ultimately I'd be quite happy to live and let live if I didn't have to review the game. I want to believe that it might be valuable for some readers to get the perspective of a non-RPG guy, but that seems kind of stupid on its face. Whose interest does it serve for me to write a review that says, essentially, "Hell if I know?" The angle will have to be the high barrier to entry and the dedication required to wring enjoyment from the game -- dedication I lack -- but it doesn't necessarily feel fair to slap a low-ish number on there. It feels definitive, and if there's one way I know I don't feel about Dragon Age, it's definitive.
*"Since we're all going to die, I feel there's one more secret I have to share with you. I did not care for Dragon Age."
"What?"
"Did not care for Dragon Age."
"How can you even say that?"
"Didn't like it."
"It's like the perfect game!"
"This is what everyone always says."
"Explain yourself. What didn't you like about it?"
"It insists upon itself. It takes forever to get into it, I... You know, I can't even finish it. I've never even finished the game."
"How can you say you don't like it if you haven't even given it a chance?"
"I have tried on three separate occasions to get through it, and I... I have no idea what they're talking about. It's like they're speaking a different language."
"The language they're speaking is the language of tactical role-playing, something you don't understand."
"I loved Final Fantasy X. That is my answer to that statement."
Cf.
Friday, November 06, 2009
Friday afternoon tidbits
Week one of National Novel Writing Month seems to be going well, at least where word count is concerned. Quality, not so much. That's the point! But with Dragon Age on the docket, week two promises to be much more challenging. Fortunately, there's always time for links.
-Paste posted their list of the 20 best games of the decade, to which I contributed both a ballot and a blurb for the #5 pick. For the most part it's an unsurprising list, though Guitar Hero III at number 10 strikes me as a disgrace. Otherwise there are a bunch of games I loved (Portal, BioShock, Shadow of the Colossus), and a bunch of games I didn't love but can't quibble with their inclusion (Halo, Grand Theft Auto, even Metal Gear Solid 2). People love to bitch about lists, but not as much as publishers love publishing them.
-I didn't see the video before it got pulled, but apparently Infinity Ward released a promotional video for Modern Warfare 2 in which Philadelphia Phillies pitcher Cole Hamels warned players against being grenade-throwing pussies, in a mock PSA brought to you by "Fight Against Grenade Spam." Har, har. There have been several decent reactions to the promo from around the web, but I think Denis's gets the closest to the root of the problem.
People seem to think that if stuff like this isn't "intended" to be hateful, then it isn't. There is some strange logic by which people convince themselves that if they call somebody a fag meaning that the person is an asshole, and not a homosexual, that somehow drains the word of bigotry. But of course that's silly. That's exactly where its power comes from. We have to be responsible about things like this, in the same way that we wouldn't walk around carelessly brandishing a weapon.
(Regarding the somewhat bizarre objection I've seen in a few comments threads that people should also be complaining about the violence in the game: That's irrelevant to the subject. Obviously everybody is welcome to criticize violence as entertainment, if they so choose, but it's really not the same thing. Besides which, conflict through violence is one of the oldest forms of drama, and I, for one, am not comfortable criticizing a game's portrayal of violence until I have the full context. I'd be happy to know of any extenuating context for a commercial that employs anti-gay slurs to sell a game. By the same token, I'd have no problem playing a game with homophobic characters in it, but I'd have a problem playing a game with homophobic depictions of characters. That's the difference.)
-The Boston Globe ran an article about computer and game addiction earlier this week, and while it's obviously an interesting subject, it's kind of weird to distinguish this from any other addiction. If you do anything to excess, it's a problem, whether that means drinking yourself into oblivion or being the crazy cat lady I saw on an episode of A&E's Hoarders. Still, it is of course helpful to be aware of the signs of compulsive behavior.
-It's a little late for Halloween, but I wanted to spotlight the Phoenix's new geek-lifestyle blog, Laser Orgy. Last week they ran a list of the 10 games that shouldn't have scared them, but did. I tried to suggest some things, but it was a lot harder to do than you might have expected.
-You know, I think I need to rep some new and different gaming blogs in my reader. Anybody have any suggestions?
-Paste posted their list of the 20 best games of the decade, to which I contributed both a ballot and a blurb for the #5 pick. For the most part it's an unsurprising list, though Guitar Hero III at number 10 strikes me as a disgrace. Otherwise there are a bunch of games I loved (Portal, BioShock, Shadow of the Colossus), and a bunch of games I didn't love but can't quibble with their inclusion (Halo, Grand Theft Auto, even Metal Gear Solid 2). People love to bitch about lists, but not as much as publishers love publishing them.
-I didn't see the video before it got pulled, but apparently Infinity Ward released a promotional video for Modern Warfare 2 in which Philadelphia Phillies pitcher Cole Hamels warned players against being grenade-throwing pussies, in a mock PSA brought to you by "Fight Against Grenade Spam." Har, har. There have been several decent reactions to the promo from around the web, but I think Denis's gets the closest to the root of the problem.
People seem to think that if stuff like this isn't "intended" to be hateful, then it isn't. There is some strange logic by which people convince themselves that if they call somebody a fag meaning that the person is an asshole, and not a homosexual, that somehow drains the word of bigotry. But of course that's silly. That's exactly where its power comes from. We have to be responsible about things like this, in the same way that we wouldn't walk around carelessly brandishing a weapon.
(Regarding the somewhat bizarre objection I've seen in a few comments threads that people should also be complaining about the violence in the game: That's irrelevant to the subject. Obviously everybody is welcome to criticize violence as entertainment, if they so choose, but it's really not the same thing. Besides which, conflict through violence is one of the oldest forms of drama, and I, for one, am not comfortable criticizing a game's portrayal of violence until I have the full context. I'd be happy to know of any extenuating context for a commercial that employs anti-gay slurs to sell a game. By the same token, I'd have no problem playing a game with homophobic characters in it, but I'd have a problem playing a game with homophobic depictions of characters. That's the difference.)
-The Boston Globe ran an article about computer and game addiction earlier this week, and while it's obviously an interesting subject, it's kind of weird to distinguish this from any other addiction. If you do anything to excess, it's a problem, whether that means drinking yourself into oblivion or being the crazy cat lady I saw on an episode of A&E's Hoarders. Still, it is of course helpful to be aware of the signs of compulsive behavior.
-It's a little late for Halloween, but I wanted to spotlight the Phoenix's new geek-lifestyle blog, Laser Orgy. Last week they ran a list of the 10 games that shouldn't have scared them, but did. I tried to suggest some things, but it was a lot harder to do than you might have expected.
-You know, I think I need to rep some new and different gaming blogs in my reader. Anybody have any suggestions?
Thursday, November 05, 2009
No rest for the wicked awesome
My review of Borderlands is up now at thephoenix.com. As you've ascertained by now, I really liked this game. I can't seem to stop playing it. I have vague memories of grumbling my way through the first few hours, making mental notes of everything to complain about. Not that there's nothing to complain about -- is that ever the case? But this game gives so much and asks so little in return that it'd feel tacky to run down a list of problems.
Actually, here's one major complaint: I haven't reached level 50 yet. Damn you, Gearbox!
Actually, here's one major complaint: I haven't reached level 50 yet. Damn you, Gearbox!
Labels:
Borderlands,
PC,
PlayStation 3,
Reviews,
Xbox 360
Tuesday, November 03, 2009
Gamestop.com User-Submitted Previews: Modern Warfare 2
With only one week to go until the release of Modern Warfare 2, many charming folks are clamoring to join the fight against grenade spam. They've gathered on the MW2 "user buzz page" on Gamestop.com, where comments generally fall into four categories.
1) Sales Potential
SPARTAN B15:
Anyone who doesn't reserve is going to have to wait a couple weeks to buy it because this game is going to be sold out! There are going to be people fighting over this game.christophermaster1:
Call of Duty MW 2 will be a big hit mostly half of u.s will potentalliy buy it and i also will look forward to itking balla:
over half the world is probably gona buy this.2) Quality Assurance
pizzaboycool:
This game is gonna be 10 times better than COD 4 and 100 times better than COD 5.EPiCMATT:
Theres no way this game will not be GAME OF THE YEAR!!!P.J The beast:
COD: MW2 is the best firts person shooter of the century.Renegade0528:
This is going to be the best shooter 2 date.Kilr Stud:
There is a very good chance that this will be the best game ever.Forster:
Personally, I think this is going to be the greatest game ever created for any game console.AIRO:
This will be the best game ever created.RE fan!:
this an 11 outa 10 game without a doubt3) Sickness Quotient
UberBerger:
This game however looks sicker than anything I have ever seen.AIRO:
The graphics look sick and the gameplay looks sick. Everything about this game will be sickking balla:
man this game looks siiiiiiiiiik.4) Cries for Help
Kristoph44:
you can say i'm preety much pumped for it and you can be sure i'm picking it up at midnight and playing it for about 3 months straight without sleep even tho it is impossible i'll still try to attempt it!!!A Customer:
im not going to get it right away not sure why i think im going to get borderlands first. o and to answer friar's question operation flashpoint: dragon rising blew cod 4 out of the water o and next time dont sound like a 3rd grader when righting your preview thing.Dawn of war fan:
This game is going to be infested with little kids. Oh god i seriously mean it. I wont be able to enjoy this game because of all the little children bantering about nothing. Talking everyone ears off.OzCueball:
I'm just afraid that it will be too over hyped and not deliver on the expectations that the hype and ads are making it out to be. I'm praying i'm wrong and it blows everyones minds and is the best selling game of all time, but if i were Infinity Ward i'd be shaking in my shoes right now in fear. Who ever reads this pray with me that i'm wrong. Just pray.
Monday, November 02, 2009
Your level best
It's amazing what a powerful motivator leveling up can be. In any game with roleplaying elements, the promise of dinging the next level is what keeps you grinding through repetitive and, let's be honest, often un-fun gameplay. You know your hard work now will pay off later. (Sometimes much later.)
Borderlands does a better job than most of keeping you focused on this goal. Your XP progress bar is always shown on your HUD, right in the center of the screen. When it's nearly full, you'll do almost anything to push it over the top. When it's nearly empty, it's so shameful that you need to redeem yourself by taking on as many missions as you can.
But Borderlands also discourages grinding in the traditional sense. The difference in XP awarded is enormous, depending on whether you're killing garden-variety enemies or completing missions. My soldier character is at level 34 now, and I'd guess that I've only leveled up in the ordinary run of play once or twice. Every other time, it's either been upon killing a boss, or turning in missions.
The way the missions are stacked is pretty clever. They're not clever quests on their own -- almost all of the "go here and get this" variety. You can accept several missions at a time, though, and you don't earn your XP at the moment you've completed the objective. You have to turn in, which usually means returning to the place where you picked up the assignment. This is often very far away. As a result, it's easier to complete multiple mission objectives at the same time, and have several quests in your mission log marked as ready to turn in. Then you'll turn them all in at once for 40 or 50 thousand XP.
Missions are categorized by difficulty, according to level. If you're at level 25, a level 25 mission will be designated as "normal" difficulty, while a level 27 mission will be "difficult" and level 23 will be "trivial." These are often correct, and it's astounding what a difference a level makes. When the League of Extraordinarily Gentle Men first broached Old Haven, one of the best designed "dungeons" in Borderlands, we were ripped to shreds. Our first encounter ended with several deaths, a couple of revivals, and a hasty retreat. Two levels later, a couple of us went back in, and although it was still challenging, we accomplished our objective without ever risking failure.
Gearbox dangles one more carrot in front of you during the course of play. It's not uncommon to find weapons that can't be used until you've reached a certain level. Your inventory is pretty small in this game, even as it can be expanded over the course of play, yet it's impossible not to allocate one crucial spot to the bitchin-est sniper rifle you've ever seen, which sets dudes on fire and never needs to be reloaded, knowing that it will all have been worth it in eight hours or so when you've finally leveled up enough to use it.
With each level boost, your character grows appreciably stronger. Your bullets do more damage. Enemy attacks hurt less. The action points that you assign become exponentially more useful. My ammo-regenerating turret still isn't very useful for supplying my teammates, but no longer is it a wimpy sidekick. It fires in five-shot bursts, with my choice of elemental power. And with a much reduced cooldown, I can toss it onto the field numerous times per battle. I finally agree with Roland when he exclaims, "I love this damn thing!"
A few times before, I've mentioned that games are often more like work than they are like play, and Borderlands is a great example. Much of it is about putting your head down and taking care of business. Gearbox did such a good job of spacing out the rewards, and making sure that one is always visible around the corner, that it rarely falls into the trap of feeling like a simple grind. Sure, it's like work, but payday is every day.
Friday, October 30, 2009
Friday afternoon tidbits
Going to be an interesting weekend. I made the mistake of signing up for National Novel Writing Month, which starts on Sunday. There goes my November.
-Brinstar wrote an interesting and all-encompassing look at Uncharted 2. Her comments on the game's portrayal of its female characters are right on. Despite the hyper-sexualized appearance of Chloe, both of the female leads are given actual personalities and motivations. Even better, they act like adults. They're not catty broads who fight over our bashful hero. Brinstar says that "[creative director] Amy Hennig stood her ground on gender issues like this many times over," which certainly wouldn't surprise me, and goes to show how much your game can be improved when you have a diversity of voices onboard.
-Torchlight seems to be dominating a lot of people's time right now. Elysium at Gamers with Jobs writes about the joy of being surprised by a game, which is something I couldn't agree with more. There's some fun in anticipating things, yes, but it always seems like you're setting yourself up for disappointment if you get too excited. Much better to be gobsmacked by something out of nowhere. (Re: Torchlight, it sounds interesting, but I can only accommodate one soul-consuming dungeon crawler at a time, and there's this game called Borderlands.)
-Shawn Elliott (him again?) predicts the upcoming controversy about Modern Warfare 2. I've not yet watched the opening sequence of the game, and in fact wish I didn't know anything about it before playing the game (thanks, Twitter!). Still, I respected the way that Call of Duty 4 coldly regarded the devastating impact of modern military technology, and I would expect its sequel to similarly pull no punches. The notion of killing civilians is, of course, shocking. I suspect that is the intent. Without context, it's impossible for us to say yet whether this serves a greater philosophical point, or, at least, a compelling narrative.
-Congratulations to Ben and the gang at Critical Distance, whose "Week in Game Criticism" roundups are now being syndicated at GSW and Gamasutra. Here's hoping this means a whole new audience for all the great writers Ben spotlights each week. And that he starts including Insult Swordfighting more often!
-Brinstar wrote an interesting and all-encompassing look at Uncharted 2. Her comments on the game's portrayal of its female characters are right on. Despite the hyper-sexualized appearance of Chloe, both of the female leads are given actual personalities and motivations. Even better, they act like adults. They're not catty broads who fight over our bashful hero. Brinstar says that "[creative director] Amy Hennig stood her ground on gender issues like this many times over," which certainly wouldn't surprise me, and goes to show how much your game can be improved when you have a diversity of voices onboard.
-Torchlight seems to be dominating a lot of people's time right now. Elysium at Gamers with Jobs writes about the joy of being surprised by a game, which is something I couldn't agree with more. There's some fun in anticipating things, yes, but it always seems like you're setting yourself up for disappointment if you get too excited. Much better to be gobsmacked by something out of nowhere. (Re: Torchlight, it sounds interesting, but I can only accommodate one soul-consuming dungeon crawler at a time, and there's this game called Borderlands.)
-Shawn Elliott (him again?) predicts the upcoming controversy about Modern Warfare 2. I've not yet watched the opening sequence of the game, and in fact wish I didn't know anything about it before playing the game (thanks, Twitter!). Still, I respected the way that Call of Duty 4 coldly regarded the devastating impact of modern military technology, and I would expect its sequel to similarly pull no punches. The notion of killing civilians is, of course, shocking. I suspect that is the intent. Without context, it's impossible for us to say yet whether this serves a greater philosophical point, or, at least, a compelling narrative.
-Congratulations to Ben and the gang at Critical Distance, whose "Week in Game Criticism" roundups are now being syndicated at GSW and Gamasutra. Here's hoping this means a whole new audience for all the great writers Ben spotlights each week. And that he starts including Insult Swordfighting more often!
Thursday, October 29, 2009
Aquaman, you go... talk to some fish!
Every heroic alliance has a weak link. The Justice League has Aquaman. The Avengers had Ant-Man. And the League of Extraordinarily Gentle Men has me.
Oh, you don't know that last one? That's the name we've given to our trio of Borderlands players. Except for a short single-player session the first day I had the game, I've played almost exclusively with the LXGM. Without going too deeply into detail, since I've still got a review to write, it's clear that Borderlands is an entirely different beast when you're playing with others. By yourself, it's a grind whose occasional rewards are overshadowed by lots of problems. With a group, not only do those problems go away, but character building starts to matter much more. Your skills affect those of your teammates, both in combat and character development. You may equip a class mod that boosts everybody's EXP by 20%, or grants everybody ammo regeneration.
Your skill trees also become more important. Each class can develop along three different tracks, so you can mix and match a few abilities, or specialize. Because the LXGM had two Soldiers, me and Bob, we decided to spend our action points developing unique tracks. Bob has been upgrading his medic skills; I've been going the support route. We're around level 30 now, and the stuff Bob can do is impressive. His turret casts a healing aura that quickly regenerates teammates' health. It has a chance to instantly revive downed players.
The best thing Bob can do is shoot healing bullets. He simply blasts away at teammates, and their health increases with the damage his gun deals. The ability doesn't require specific weapons or rare ammo. He can damage enemies and heal teammates in the same burst. It's helpful during firefights and after -- when the medic is playing, you don't even need to carry around medkits. This might be the most useful skill I've ever seen in a game of this type.
As the support gunner, I've felt a little bit less indispensable. My turret regenerates team ammo instead of health. Here's a little secret about Borderlands: you will never run out of ammo. Enemies drop it in spades. It's the most common thing you find in chests. It's cheap to buy at stores. And some teammates don't even need it.
The third member of the LXGM, Greg, has been doing yeoman's work as two different characters. At first he mostly used the Berserker, whose special skill is not using guns. His fists can pummel enemies into goo. It wasn't uncommon to follow Greg into an area and see his character standing there, screaming, on top of a pile of crushed corpses. All that without firing a single shot. Then he started playing as a Hunter, who probably would need ammo if he hadn't found a legendary revolver that drops most enemies in one shot, and, oh yeah, regenerates bullets.
Borderlands does let you respec, for a fee. You can buy back all your action points and redistribute them as you see fit. We certainly don't need a second medic. I could pump up my guy's firearm abilities on the infantry track, if I wanted to. But I think I'll keep him the way he is. There's dignity in making your choices and sticking to them. My Roland is a support gunner. He was born to provide ammo to people who don't need it. Damn it, that's what he's going to do.
Besides, every team of great heroes needs its useless character. That's one thing I know I can excel at.
Friday, October 23, 2009
Friday afternoon tidbits
Busy weekend ahead, highlighted by a (hopefully) long Borderlands session. The jump in fun factor between single-player and co-op is enormous with this game. Single player has its rewards, but they're tough to appreciate amid some problems. In multiplayer, the joy rains down from the heavens, and there is no shelter. Excellent game. And not the kind of thing I'd have expected to like so much.
To the links!
-Clink Hocking's Click Nothing Tour hits the road this Sunday. He'll be in my neck of the woods on Wednesday at MIT. Sadly, it's at 4 in the afternoon, which makes it difficult if not impossible for me to attend. I will try.
-Brandon Sheffield intervewed Suda 51 for Gamasutra. Suda is a fascinating guy whose games are always singular creations, and he has some interesting things to say here. Still, I don't know if it's the language barrier or what, but he's also a little curt. You get exchanges like this.
-Via Game|Life, tickets are now available for PAX East! It'll be held in Boston from March 26-28, 2010. I've never been to an expo like this before, but I suppose there's no way I can duck one taking place in my backyard. I'm still hoping there's some way I can get in for free, maybe by sneaking in through the vents.
-Two interesting takes on the evolution of difficulty in games. Michael Abbott compares the Wii remake of A Boy and His Blob to the original, while C.T. Hutt revisits Earthworm Jim and finds it more challenging than he remembers. User experience is a big reason why games are easier nowadays, but I think there's an even more prosaic explanation.
In the past, games were so short that they had to be incredibly difficult in order to be worth playing. Once you know how to beat a game like Contra, you can blow through it in about 20 minutes. If you could do that on your first or second playthrough, it wouldn't seem like much of a game at all. Even though we often complain about the length of 8-10 hour games today, most of them are significantly longer than comparable titles of 20 years ago. Even a game like Super Metroid, whose gameworld seemed massive at the time, today takes about 4 hours to beat. That's nothing.
(One more example: It took me 12 years to beat Super Mario Bros. We got the Nintendo when I was 6, and I finally beat it when I was 18. Shortly thereafter, I played through the first three Super Mario Bros. games in about an hour.)
-Not related to video games, but I need to thank Kyle Orland for linking the "Eye On Springfield" tumblog in his Twitter feed. This site has improved my life in ways I cannot possibly quantify.
All right, screw this "reading" thing. Pandora awaits!
To the links!
-Clink Hocking's Click Nothing Tour hits the road this Sunday. He'll be in my neck of the woods on Wednesday at MIT. Sadly, it's at 4 in the afternoon, which makes it difficult if not impossible for me to attend. I will try.
-Brandon Sheffield intervewed Suda 51 for Gamasutra. Suda is a fascinating guy whose games are always singular creations, and he has some interesting things to say here. Still, I don't know if it's the language barrier or what, but he's also a little curt. You get exchanges like this.
Honestly, I think that that's kind of what art is about, when you just create something and other people put their own meaning into it. I can see that as a critique of voyeurism, while to you, it's just something you made.Thanks for showing up, Suda.
GS: Art? Mmm...
-Via Game|Life, tickets are now available for PAX East! It'll be held in Boston from March 26-28, 2010. I've never been to an expo like this before, but I suppose there's no way I can duck one taking place in my backyard. I'm still hoping there's some way I can get in for free, maybe by sneaking in through the vents.
-Two interesting takes on the evolution of difficulty in games. Michael Abbott compares the Wii remake of A Boy and His Blob to the original, while C.T. Hutt revisits Earthworm Jim and finds it more challenging than he remembers. User experience is a big reason why games are easier nowadays, but I think there's an even more prosaic explanation.
In the past, games were so short that they had to be incredibly difficult in order to be worth playing. Once you know how to beat a game like Contra, you can blow through it in about 20 minutes. If you could do that on your first or second playthrough, it wouldn't seem like much of a game at all. Even though we often complain about the length of 8-10 hour games today, most of them are significantly longer than comparable titles of 20 years ago. Even a game like Super Metroid, whose gameworld seemed massive at the time, today takes about 4 hours to beat. That's nothing.
(One more example: It took me 12 years to beat Super Mario Bros. We got the Nintendo when I was 6, and I finally beat it when I was 18. Shortly thereafter, I played through the first three Super Mario Bros. games in about an hour.)
-Not related to video games, but I need to thank Kyle Orland for linking the "Eye On Springfield" tumblog in his Twitter feed. This site has improved my life in ways I cannot possibly quantify.
All right, screw this "reading" thing. Pandora awaits!
Wednesday, October 21, 2009
Chart-topper
My review of Uncharted 2 is up at thephoenix.com. (No, that post on Monday wasn't a review.) To add to the chorus: It's great. Really great. This game doesn't step wrong. Like Metroid Prime and the Half-Life games, it's so confident and assured that you may forget you're playing a game for long stretches of time.
Frankly, I think people are overusing the "cinematic" descriptor for this game. I get why they say that, but if anything Uncharted 2 shows some of the ways in which games can be superior to movies for delivering action-adventure entertainment. As for the storyline and characters, okay, those are almost good enough to be called movie-like.
And now your note of caution (okay, cynicism). Uncharted 2 is the kind of game that is tailor-made for the reviewing experience. It's not terribly long, it's linear, and it doesn't repeat itself. That's where my tastes run anyway, but it's worth mentioning. Ordinarily this isn't something I'd stop to consider, but having moved on to the more professionally challenging Borderlands, I long for the halcyon days of last week, when I could sit down and blow through a game in one sitting, reasonably certain that I hadn't missed anything important.
There will, of course, be more about Borderlands to come.
Monday, October 19, 2009
The minimalism of Uncharted 2
By now, you may have heard about a little game called Uncharted 2: Among Thieves. You've heard how cinematic it is, how lifelike the graphics are, and how large-scale the action sequences are. It's all true. Sony's VP of Big Action Scenes is not lying to you.
Nobody seems to have put their finger on the true reason for the success of this game, though, which is what isn't there. Lots of games have great production values, with shiny graphics and booming audio bespeaking a massive budget. Yet most of them never achieve greatness, and while the reasons are different in every case, often it comes down to one or two root causes. Either the interface is overly complicated or unsuited to the in-game tasks (like Killzone 2, say), or the designers are reluctant to cut things they've worked so hard on even if it would improve the whole product (a good example of this is Prototype).* Naughty Dog nailed both of those things.
The interface would probably still be hard for a gaming neophyte to pick up, but for veterans of 3D action-adventures, it's remarkably elegant. For some reason, other developers force players to hold down a button to make their character run. Not only does that miss the entire point of having analog control sticks, but it also commits one of the buttons to an unnecessary function. Even with all the buttons on gamepads today, they're still a limited resource. By using the analog stick to make Nathan run, Naughty Dog frees up the face buttons for more important uses.
Another thing Nathan can't do is crouch -- at least, not on his own. If the player presses the button to take cover, and the nearest bit of cover is low, he will duck behind that. Again, it's a sensible solution, based on a realistic accounting of how players will want and need Nathan to move. I was a little surprised at first that I couldn't press a button to make him crouch, but after about an hour of gameplay I realized that it wasn't actually necessary. I was grateful to be able to clear that out of my brainspace while I was playing.
Nathan does a lot of climbing, swinging, and shimmying, which always has the potential to be a bear. Some games have done this stuff better than others. Although a lot of people liked the magnetic approach of inFamous, I thought it was intrusive. Uncharted 2 has a little bit of auto-assist too, but it's much more subtle. Nathan will turn and grab a ledge if you walk off it, but not if you run or jump off. Instead of being sucked toward grabbable objects in mid-air, most of Nathan's jumps are directed in such a way that you can't help but move in the right direction to begin with. This is the advantage of the linear, scripted approach over a more open world.
Those are some of the smaller things that Uncharted 2 does right, and they have an outsized impact on the experience. For the most part, you can forget you're even holding a controller while you're playing this game. But Naughty Dog made more brave choices with the gameplay, and I don't think they're getting credit for how much they left out.
I can only imagine how hard it must be to design video games. Imagine that some members of your team are working solely on your game's water. It needs to look right: it should reflect the light, be capable of different levels of transparency, maybe have some sand swirling around. The fluid dynamics need to be programmed just right, too, because you have a fantastic idea for a boat level. So your artists and programmers bust their asses for months, and they create the best water ever seen in a video game. What do you do?
You put water freaking everywhere.
After all, you can't let their hard work go to waste! Sure, it doesn't make sense to have water mains bursting in every single level, and that boat chase you had in mind didn't really work out, but you'll be damned if you don't share this wonderful water with the world!
That's all wild speculation on my part, but surely you've noticed things like this. Yes, it can be very hard to let go of things you've done. Unfortunately, this mindset often results in games repeating themselves. Things that are fun at first get old. Things that aren't fun at first become obnoxious. And things that don't belong in the final product are still there, because nobody had the courage to let them go.
There's not an ounce of fat in Uncharted 2. Most interesting things only happen once. Sure, there are your standard rooms full of crates to duck behind while shooting at dudes, but the shootouts never last very long, and they're often a waypoint en route to something more interesting. You hurtle forward, never getting bogged down. Enough wrinkles are introduced that the vanilla gunfights really do feel different from the ones on the train, which again are different from the ones in the trucks. The same is true of climbing sequences. Some are slower paced, allowing you to enjoy the environments, while some are more about racing against crumbling infrastructure. You don't typically repeat anything.
I don't doubt that Naughty Dog had to leave some stuff on the cutting room floor, some of it probably quite good. Somebody there must have had a laser-like focus on the final product. They took out all the right things.
*I should clarify that I liked both Killzone 2 and Prototype, the latter quite a bit. That's why they're instructive comparisons to Uncharted 2: They're well made, big-budget games that are fun to play, but are flawed in ways that could have, and should have, been addressed early in the process.
Labels:
Gamepads,
Naughty Dog,
PlayStation 3,
Uncharted 2
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











